What If Season 3 Episode 8 Review: A Somewhat Silly, But Grand Finale

What If Season 3 Episode 8 is titled ‘What If… What If?’ and it brings the series to an end. What If season finale showcases the aftermath of Peggy and her friends trying to save the Watcher. However, the Emninence is not happy with mortals in the Fifth Dimension!

  • What If Season 3 Episode 8 Director

    Bryan Andrews

  • What If Season 3 Episode 8 Writers

    Story by : Bryan Andrews, Matthew Chauncey, and Ryan Little
    Teleplay by : Matthew Chauncey and Ryan Little

  • What If Season 3 Episode 8 Cast

    Hayley Atwell, Jason Isaacs, Devery Jacobs, Alison Sealy-Smith, Natasha Lyonne, D. C. Douglas, Darin De Paul

  • What If Finale Release Date

    29 December 2024

The episode has a runtime of 30 minutes.

What If Season 3 Episode: Jeffrey Wright as the Watcher
What If Season 3 Episode: Jeffrey Wright as the Watcher

What If Season 3 Episode 8 Ending Explained and Recap

Episode 8 starts with the Watcher being introduced to his new role by the Emninence, mentioning that although not everyone can handle taking in so much, he can since he is a disciple of the Order of the Watchers. Although the Watcher is unsure of his new role, the Emninence mentions that asking “what if” doesn’t matter. The Watcher mentions that to watch over everyone, he must become no one, prompting the Emninence to declare that he is ready to take on his task.

Back to the present, the Watcher and the Eminence, the Incarnate and the Executioner argue about the validity of his decisions and giving away their secrets to mortal beings. Although the Watcher takes them to be miracles, the others do not agree with such claims. They call his decisions unnecessary but deem Peggy to be the most dangerous, bringing her in front of the Watcher. They tell him that no one’s lives matter for a Watcher but Peggy disagrees, reminding him that he taught her that “no one is no one”. Hearing this, the Eminence tells him that this is why he will have to die.

What If Season 3 Episode: Jeffrey Wright as the Watcher, Hayley Atwell as Peggy Carter
What If Season 3 Episode: Jeffrey Wright as the Watcher, Hayley Atwell as Peggy Carter

Also Read: All What If Season 1 Articles

Just as they are about to get rid of him, Ultron and the others arrive leaving all of them shocked. As the two of them make a run for it to the ship, Ultron stays behind to stop the three others. After a tearful reconciliation, Byrdie asks the Watcher where they can go, but he tells her that is no “where to” anymore. However, Byrdie lets them know that she will take them through the seams of the multiverse in order to lose the Emninence, leaving them shocked. Although the Watcher is skeptical, Peggy decides to take them to Stephen Strange’s universe so that he can shape it to restrict their powers.

However, before they is able to get to the universe, the Emninence and others make their way to the ship, stopping them mid track. They crash on an unknown universe and then begin to fight with the three celestial beings, ending in them almost dying. The Watcher proposes that they take the oath in order to survive. Without much choice, the four of them do as they are told and just as the three beings end up destroying them, they all come back as Watchers. A fight erupts but even after being clearly overpowered, they refuse to give up. In the end, however, Uatu asks them to reconsider their stance. The three take this chance to take the last step – combining their powers to remove every trace of them from every universe ever.

What If Season 3 Episode: Jason Isaacs as the Eminence, D. C. Douglas as the Incarnate, Darin De Paul as the Executioner
What If Season 3 Episode: Jason Isaacs as the Eminence, D. C. Douglas as the Incarnate, Darin De Paul as the Executioner

Also Read: All What If Season 2 Articles

As parts of them start withering away, Peggy fights against the three of them and sacrifices herself to save her friends. When everyone comes to, the Emninence realises that his powers aren’t working anymore. Uatu realises that they are in Stephen Strange’s universe now. Finally conceding defeat, the Eminence asks Uatu how he learned so much about people and their ways and is told that there is something to learn from every corner of the multiverse. He promises to share everything that he has learnt with him, asking him to see the meaning behind things instead of just watching. The Emninence takes him up on his offer and the two of them watch the sunrise together.

Later, the group bids farewell to Peggy and the Watcher wistfully mentions that it feels like Peggy is watching over him. The episode ends with Uatu taking about the endless possibilities of the multiverse and how all of these are realities in their own right.

What If Season 3 Episode 8 Review

What If Season 3 Episode: Hayley Atwell as Peggy Carter
What If Season 3 Episode: Hayley Atwell as Peggy Carter

The episode, somehow, felt extremely convenient and oddly an expected outcome. The fight between the Watchers, everyone suddenly becoming a Watcher out of thin air and then Peggy sacrificing herself for her friends leading to the Emninence swiftly agreeing to learn from Uatu felt really easy. I feel like with a series that prides itself for being all about possibilities and whatnot, I expected it to have something truly out of the world (pun intended) and although it’s quite dramatic and action-packed, it lacked the punch. All in all, I enjoyed What If Season 3 finale, but I will say that the season had better episodes than this one.

Also Read: What If Season 3 Reviews

REVIEW OVERVIEW

Overall

SUMMARY

What If Season 3 Episode 8 is dramatic and action-packed, but nothing spectacular as one might expect!
Archi Sengupta
Archi Sengupta
Archi Sengupta, a writer for over seven years, is an Engineering graduate with a Master’s degree in Mass Communication. She enjoys watching horror movies and TV shows, Korean content, and anything that thrills and excites her.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles

Oh What Fun Review: A Depressing Christmas Flick Made Bearable Thanks to Michelle Pfeiffer

Oh What Fun Review: This is a depressing watch as it doesn't deliver on an interesting concept as it tries to shove holiday cheer down our throats.

What If Season 3 Episode 7 Review: Ultron Knows What to Do!

What If Season 3 Episode 7 is fantastic with an extremely engaging storyline, fantastic voicework and animation along with interesting character inclusions.

What If Season 3 Episode 6 Review: Emotional and Action Packed

What If Season 3 Episode 6 is fantastic, with an emotional storyline and kickass action sequences.
What If Season 3 Episode 8 is dramatic and action-packed, but nothing spectacular as one might expect!What If Season 3 Episode 8 Review: A Somewhat Silly, But Grand Finale