Picture This Review: Cliched and Tropey in the Worst Ways

In this British rom-com, Pia, whose life is a bit of a mess for the time being, gets a prediction that she will thrive both professionally and romantically within her next five dates. With her sister’s nuptials looming in the background and her desi family playing matchmaker, her ex, Charlie’s emergence throws her life for more of a loop… but maybe in the best way possible?

  • Picture This Movie Cast

    Simone Ashley, Hero Fiennes Tiffin, Sindhu Vee, Luke Fetherston, Nikesh Patel, Adil Ray, Anoushka Chadha, Eben Figueiredo, Kulvinder Ghir, Asim Chaudhry, Phil Dunster

  • Picture This Prime Video Director

    Prarthana Mohan

  • Picture This 2025 Writer

    Nikita Lalwani

  • Picture This Producers

    Ben Pugh, Erica Steinberg

The film has a runtime of 99 minutes and is based on Five Blind Dates by Shawn Seet.

Picture This Review: Simone Ashley
Picture This Review: Simone Ashley

Picture This Review

The entire thing about movies focused on Indian celebrations and customs is mostly so half-baked and surface-level that most desis find it quite tacky. The music, the pandit ji, the mother being overbearing about getting their (gasp) 30-year-old daughter married — it’s all so overdone and unimaginative at this point. It’s all played off as really humorous and oh-so-funny but I somehow found it quite insulting in a way. I mean, it was funny a few years ago, but this trope is overdone at this point and makes a mockery of our cultures in a way that makes you want to look away.

The story follows Pia who is obviously career-focused, so much so that she can’t see herself getting married. Her Indian family can’t handle the fact that she’s 30 and her younger sister is getting married and set her up on dates to meet the love of her life and do something useful with her life like, you know, getting married and having kids. I get it, there’s this notion surrounding Indians that we really love our big, fat weddings and are obsessed about having kids. But repeating the same thing over and over again in the most outlandish way possible isn’t as funny as one might expect.

Picture This Review: Simone Ashley, Hero Fiennes Tiffin
Picture This Review: Simone Ashley, Hero Fiennes Tiffin

I think what really gets me is the fact that the characters, along with the tried and tested storyline, are so surface-level. Pia is set up on dates with people she is uninterested in who have no other personality than being obnoxious or the typical nerdy Indian that Western media sees us as. There is no in-between. Pia’s gay bestie is as you’d expect any other gay best friend to be, overly sexual and friendly but at least he gets to be something more than that. The dates were clearly added as comic reliefs but they just feel like caricatures and don’t illicit the feelings that you might expect.

Picture This Review: Simone Ashley, Sindhu Vee
Picture This Review: Simone Ashley, Sindhu Vee

Hero Fiennes Tiffin, whom I have watched in After, unfortunately, is surprisingly sweet and watchable with a boyish charm to him. He and Simone Ashley, who was a memorable addition to Bridgerton, look dreamy together as they hash out their past and come to terms with their feelings in the present. Unfortunately, we don’t see a lot of the romance between them throughout the runtime, only getting glimpses and things getting better from there. Pia goes on her own journey and comes to some conclusions about her life which is commendable, but, again, nothing new. Every other movie that showcases NRIs runs in a similar vein.

Final Thoughts

Picture This Review: Simone Ashley, Hero Fiennes Tiffin
Picture This Review: Simone Ashley, Hero Fiennes Tiffin

In the end, Picture This is nothing new and makes it a point to create caricatures of Indians to get a laugh. It’s something that we have seen many times in other movies and it’s getting a bit old at this point. It’s unimaginative and cringy but some of the side plots have something going for them. I wanted to see a bit more of Fiennes Tiffin and Simone’s chemistry which we miss out on, although they make a stunning couple together. This one’s a miss in my book.

Also Read: Grosse Pointe Garden Society Episode 2 Review: Complications and Confessions

REVIEW OVERVIEW

Overall

SUMMARY

Picture This treads on cliched waters, trying to make us laugh using caricatures and using big fat Indian weddings simply as a prop.
Archi Sengupta
Archi Sengupta
Archi Sengupta, a writer for over seven years, is an Engineering graduate with a Master’s degree in Mass Communication. She enjoys watching horror movies and TV shows, Korean content, and anything that thrills and excites her.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 3 Review: This is Going to Become Messier as the Cheating Has Begun

A Love Other Than Yours episode 3 proves how two people who are exhausted in love tend to make hasty decisions.

You and Me Against the World Review: A Familiar Young-Adult Romance With a Suspenseful Twist

You+Me - Against the World brings together a secretive aspiring filmmaker and a rebellious student in a YA romance that adds family conflict and mystery to its love story.

Neagley Review: Maria Sten Leads a Promising but Familiar Reacher Spinoff

Neagley gives Maria Sten’s Frances Neagley her own gritty investigation, delivering a promising Reacher spinoff that must prove it can stand on its own.

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 1 Review: Mature Premise and a Decent Start

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 1 starts with a breakup after a decade-long relationship, introducing a mature central conflict despite its rushed and uneven storytelling.

The Revolutionaries Review: A Gritty Retelling of India’s Revolutionary Struggle

The Revolutionaries brings four lesser-known Indian freedom fighters to the forefront in Nikkhil Advani’s ambitious Prime Video period drama about armed resistance against British rule.
Picture This treads on cliched waters, trying to make us laugh using caricatures and using big fat Indian weddings simply as a prop.Picture This Review: Cliched and Tropey in the Worst Ways