A Christmas Story Christmas Review: A Plain Sequel that Mostly Rides on Nostalgia

A Christmas Story Christmas is a legacy sequel to the cult holiday-themed movie released in the year 1983. It follows the all-grown-up Ralphie (played by Peter Billingsley), who now aims to become a full-time author and recreate the magic of Christmas for his kids. The film is directed by Clay Kaytis and also written by him and Nick Schenk. Furthermore, it is based on the works of Jean Shepherd.

The complete cast of the film includes Julie Hagerty as Mrs Parker, Ian Petrella as Randy Parker, Scott Schwartz as Flick, RD Robb as Schwartz, Zack Ward as Scut Farkus, Erin Hayes as Ralphie’s wife Sandy Parker, River Drosche and Julianna Layne Ralphie’s son and daughter respectively. Moreover, the film is edited by David Walsh Heinz while Matthew Clark serves as the cinematographer.

-A Christmas Story Christmas Review Does Not Contain Spoilers-

The long-awaited sequel of the holiday classic starts with a middle-aged Ralphie (Peter Billingsley), who now lives with his family in Chicago, Illinois. The Christmas favourite kid has still not given up on his dreams and saved enough finances to pursue writing as a career (for almost one year).

The ambitious child turned into an optimistic adult is assured to return to the rat race if the gig doesn’t work out till January. Moreover, he is assisted in the process by an ever-loving wife, and two kids, who are willing to have Cornflakes with Orange juice, for the sake of their dad’s writing career. 

The movie shifts to Indiana, when Ralphie learns that his old man has passed away and that his mother will be alone this Christmas. The middle age protagonist decides to spend Christmas with her mother while reliving all the iconic memories of his childhood. He also tries to furnish the magic of the holiday but confronts one problem after another.

The basic plot of the film might exude all vibes of a perfect Christmas sequel, but the execution feels more like a short-handed attempt. Through the screenplay, the film maintains the quality of a true continuation, wrapped with several references (including the bullies), but ends up looking dull in comparison to the classic.

A Christmas Story Christmas
A still from A Christmas Story Christmas

Also Read: Dead to Me Season 3 Ending Explained: Did Jen and Judy Get Their Happy Ending?

You can spot almost all the characters from the original film, along with a flashback montage that appears every time to state the obvious. This includes the clingy hounds, Flick and Schwartz, Scut Farkus, and the reminisce of the old man (Darren McGavin). Although the moments are quite nostalgic, they don’t make up for the sequel, which is often flat at times.

In the film, Ralpie gets lost in daydreams about winning Pulitzer, curating a perfect Christmas, and seeking revenge from the bullies in the most western style possible. There are many attempts to induce laughter through these dream scenarios, but only one of them actually succeeds in generating a smirk of acknowledgement. All in all, it’s only the subtle performance of Peter Billingsley that holds the entire thing together.

A Christmas Story Christmas Final Thoughts

A Christmas Story Christmas
A still from A Christmas Story Christmas

Although the film is miles behind the original one, it does make up for a decent watch during the holiday season (mostly depending on your definition of decent). However, it reminds you so much of A Christmas Story, that you might end up rewatching the fan-favourite holiday film.

You can stream the movie on HBO Max. Let us know your thoughts about it in the comment section below.

Also Read: Urusei Yatsura Episode 6 Review: Unintentional Participant in a Battle

REVIEW OVERVIEW

Overall

SUMMARY

A Christmas Story Christmas is the long-awaited sequel to the holiday classic, that finds a middle-aged Ralphie, making all efforts to recreate the magic of Christmas for his kids.
Manjeet Singh
Manjeet Singh
Manjeet loves to steer conversations around films and pop culture(usually to the point of no return). Finding obscure movies and consuming their Wikipedia literature is his daytime hobby. Being a hopeless romantic about cinema is what keeps him going.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles

Elf Me Review: The Usual Christmas Mayhem

Elf Me Review: Offering a familiar ride into the Christmas season, the new Prime Video movie is enjoyable if you put aside any big expectations.

8 Best Feel Good Movies to Watch on New Year’s Eve: About Time, Clueless, Little Miss Sunshine and More

Looking for some heartwarming inspiration to welcome the coming year with good spirits? Then check out these best feel good movies to watch on New Year's eve.

A Not So Merry Christmas Ending Explained: Did Chuy Break the Curse or Worsened It?

A Not So Merry Christmas ended beautifully with a meaningful message. Want to know what it is? Read on.

Christmas 2022: Netflix Movies That Can Ruin the Holiday Mood

Christmas 2022: Netflix movies that you better avoid to keep up the festive spirit this year!

A Not So Merry Christmas Review: A Not So Typical Hilarious Time Loop Story

A Not So Merry Christmas movie is a fun packed family movie. Read on to find whether it is worth the hype.
A Christmas Story Christmas is the long-awaited sequel to the holiday classic, that finds a middle-aged Ralphie, making all efforts to recreate the magic of Christmas for his kids.A Christmas Story Christmas Review: A Plain Sequel that Mostly Rides on Nostalgia