PI Meena Review: Tanya Maniktala is an Annoying “Detective” in a Convoluted Story

PI Meena Review: Starring a whole host of talented actors, including Tanya Maniktala, Parambrata Chattopadhyay, Saurav Das, Jisshu Sengupta, Zarina Wahab, Vinay Pathak, Samir Soni and others, this Mystery-thriller series is directed by Debaloy Bhattacharya. With writing credits going to Arindam Mitra, as well as co-writers Ronak Kamat and Vipin Sharma, and music by Amit Chatterjee and Rohit Kulkarni, the Amazon Prime Video series has 8 episodes, each with a runtime of around 40 minutes.

PI Meena Plot

Grappling with a personal tragedy from years ago, Meenakshi Iyer gets pulled into a complicated and confusing case at her day job that results in her going deeper and deeper into a bigger conspiracy that she was never ready for. Spanning several states but taking place primarily in Kolkata, Meena goes on a dangerous adventure that puts her life in danger at every moment.

– PI Meena Review Does Not Contain Spoilers –

PI Meena Review

PI Meena review

The mystery genre is a fun time for all, regardless of age – a shadowy organisation, with words like Big Pharma popping up here and there to make us think of a bigger conspiracy, a woman with a streak for doing the right thing, and a viral outbreak after COVID. All the trappings of a great show, right?

Weirdly enough, PI Meena feels a little like The Jengaburu Case in some ways, with bigger conspiracies that endanger locals and a connection with people we wouldn’t have thought of before. It’s a cliched storyline at this point that starts with something small and then moves rapidly towards something shocking.

The first thing that I thought of after watching PI Meena is that Meenakshi’s workplace is quite lax when it comes to her work. For 8 episodes, she runs around solving a random case that has nothing to do with her day job, gets shot at, gets colleagues to work on this big thing and causes a ruckus at an ex-client’s house. It’s wild to see how her job is ok with her doing these things and going off-script constantly. I wish we all had jobs wherein we could simply do anything we wanted at our jobs and get away with it!

PI Meena review

Coming to the case at hand, the series follows story threads of several people that come together as one eventually – something that we seem to be getting a lot of these days. Most shows these days focus on some big conspiracy in the higher levels of society that is out to wipe out chunks of people in the country. It’s not too much of a far-off concept, and conspiracy lovers will have a field day with the madness that comes with topics such as these, but with several shows now focusing on the same story-telling technique, you will be able to figure out what’s happening from a mile away.

Meenakshi Iyer, although a private detective, feels like a petulant schoolchild who is annoyed with everything and everyone. Her attitude is annoying, and although I get that she’s going through stuff in her personal life, she comes off as someone who is unprofessional and, thus, someone we can’t really follow. She doesn’t follow rules, which is fine for a protagonist in a conspiracy story, but she is also quite unbothered about the consequences of her actions, which feels annoying and selfish.

Also Read: 5 Times Shah Rukh Khan Redefined Romance On Screen With His Dedication Towards His Lover

PI Meena review

The storyline is quite convoluted, with stuff happening all over the place. Now, things like this are believable, but the way the story goes about with this story is unbelievably silly. It’s not like there are not enough twists of the people who aren’t interesting enough or without depth; most have something or the other going for them. However, the central mystery that we follow is just plain boring. The story’s flow is so incredibly jarring that focusing on one single thing at a time is extremely hard.

As PI Meena reaches the last few episodes, it just gets worse. The storyline is all over the place, with several plot holes and the worst of all – it ends on a cliffhanger. I don’t know what it is with streaming platforms these days, but they just release everything in several instalments, regardless of whether or not the audience wants that. A convoluted and cliched storyline like this, which could’ve been better if there was some resolution of some kind, also ends on a random note in the middle of the Howrah Bridge because why not?

Also Read: Hurricane Season Review: Subjective Narratives Add Layers to Disturbing Realities of Squalor Under the Garb of a Murder Mystery

PI Meena review

Let’s not even talk about how everyone around Meenakshi speaks in Hindi when the entire storyline takes place in Kolkata. At least it’s full of Bengali actors who nail their dictions and don’t just blurt out random cliched phrases to showcase that they are, in fact, Bengali. However, everyone looks a bit awkward in the series for some reason which makes viewing this all the more confusing and annoying.

Also, Alexa users might want to use earphones for this one and be prepared for some unnecessary, god-awful jumpscares that pop up randomly and for no reason because this isn’t a horror show, just a detective one.

PI Meena Review: Final Thoughts

PI Meena Review: Tanya Maniktala is an Annoying "Detective" in a Convoluted Story

In the end, PI Meena is a confusing and unnecessary series that doesn’t bring forth anything new or exciting. Although there is a thrilling story there somewhere, it doesn’t do a good job of bringing it forth and instead goes round and round with a boring story and a very annoying protagonist who just does whatever she wants without any thoughts about others. Honestly, there are better stories out there.

PI Meena is streaming on Amazon Prime Video.

Also Read: Koffee With Karan Season 8 Episode 2 Recap and Review: Sunny Deol and Bobby Deol Discuss Nepotism, Gadar 2 Success and More


Discover more from Leisurebyte

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

REVIEW OVERVIEW

Overall

SUMMARY

PI Meena Review: Tanya Maniktala, Parambrata Chattopadhyay Star in a rather annoying thriller!
Archi Sengupta
Archi Sengupta
Archi Sengupta, a writer for over seven years, is an Engineering graduate with a Master’s degree in Mass Communication. She enjoys watching horror movies and TV shows, Korean content, and anything that thrills and excites her.

LEAVE A REPLY

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 10 Review: Love That Was Never Honest

A Love Other Than Yours episode 10 dives into how even a long relationship could have been a fake one.

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 9 Review: The Time We Fell in Love

A Love Other Than Yours episode 9 is all about two adults who are still protecting their inner child.

Masterplan Movie Review: Can Stanley Tucci’s Heist Comedy Steal the Show?

Stanley Tucci leads Masterplan, a Prime Video heist comedy about a legendary thief, the Mona Lisa and two long-lost siblings who discover their unexpected family connection.

Love Of Your Life Review: Margaret Qualley Leads an Uneven Emotional Story of Love and Loss on Prime Video

Love of Your Life follows a woman navigating grief and rediscovering herself after a devastating loss. Margaret Qualley anchors this emotional romantic drama, although uneven pacing and familiar storytelling prevent it from reaching its full potential.

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 8 Review: Peak Ragebait Series

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 8 continues the complicated relationship drama surrounding Ho and Mi-do, as unresolved feelings and strained relationships keep their romantic journey uncertain.
PI Meena Review: Tanya Maniktala, Parambrata Chattopadhyay Star in a rather annoying thriller!PI Meena Review: Tanya Maniktala is an Annoying "Detective" in a Convoluted Story