One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review: A Confusing, Heinous Crime Told Well

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review: On the early morning of November 13, 2022, four young college students were found murdered in their off-campus college house at 1122 King Road in Moscow, Idaho. The Prime Video documentary series showcases the horrifying reality, the heartbreak of everyone close to the victims and the investigation that followed.

  • One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Prime Video Directors

    Liz Garbus, Matthew Galkin

  • One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Documentary Release Date

    11 July 2025

The series has 4 episodes, each with a runtime of around 45 minutes.

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review: Karen Laramie (Maddie Mogen’s mother)
One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review: Karen Laramie (Maddie Mogen’s mother)

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review

The 2022 Idaho murders left shockwaves across America because the incident just came out of left field for everyone. Of course, no one really thinks their loved ones will face such a horrible situation, but the university town, especially, had not seen a murder since 2015, so the shocking turn of events was nothing short of confusing. However, the docuseries focuses heavily on the parents’ and the other students’ feelings surrounding this horrible situation, which leaves your heart heavy from the first episode.

From the first episode, we go on a journey through the trauma of the four families losing their loved ones in a crime that they can’t make sense of. It’s devastating and confusing for the viewers as well, who can’t, along with the families, understand why something like this happened. Even if you know the outcome of the situation, the docuseries does a good job of bringing to the screen this fear of the unknown that will leave you hooked to figure out what happened in the college town.

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review: Hunter Chapin (Ethan Chapin’s brother)
One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review: Hunter Chapin (Ethan Chapin’s brother)

One of the most interesting parts of the series is that it focuses heavily on the media circus that followed the incident, specifically how ravenous internet sleuths became to publicly prosecute innocent students who were already fearful for their lives. With no answers to who committed the murders and why, the internet became desperate to pin the blame on someone, publicly shaming and destroying the reputations of innocents who did nothing but exist around their friends. It’s done well and makes you fear for the future of our society. The vitriol people throw at others without knowing anything about them is honestly just heartbreaking and shocking.

It’s the parents, however, that almost brought me to tears. The series, as mentioned, focuses on the families’ testimonies to bring the devastation of the situation home. It almost feels personal every time one of the parents’ voices breaks or they look confused, 3 years after the fact. It proves how, regardless of the time that has passed, you simply can’t get over the heartbreak of losing a loved one, especially your child. The docuseries takes the situation seriously, and the grim atmosphere just adds to the sadness that engulfs the series because it is exactly that sad.

Final Thoughts

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review: Ethan Chapin, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, Madison Mogen
One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review: Ethan Chapin, Kaylee Goncalves, Xana Kernodle, Madison Mogen

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders is a heartbreaking watch. The docuseries does a great job of holding on to the heartbreak, the confusion and the tension that surrounds the case. Bryan Kohberger, the accused, just agreed to the murders, and the docuseries comes at a very raw time to rehash everything that happened in 2022. This one’s going to leave you teary-eyed.

Also Read: Ballard Review: Although Not Icon Like Bosch, But Still Entertaining


Discover more from Leisurebyte

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

REVIEW OVERVIEW

Overall

SUMMARY

One Night in Idaho: The College Murders is a hard-hitting watch and will leave you heartbroken and confused.
Archi Sengupta
Archi Sengupta
Archi Sengupta, a writer for over seven years, is an Engineering graduate with a Master’s degree in Mass Communication. She enjoys watching horror movies and TV shows, Korean content, and anything that thrills and excites her.

LEAVE A REPLY

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related Articles

Masterplan Movie Review: Can Stanley Tucci’s Heist Comedy Steal the Show?

Stanley Tucci leads Masterplan, a Prime Video heist comedy about a legendary thief, the Mona Lisa and two long-lost siblings who discover their unexpected family connection.

Love Of Your Life Review: Margaret Qualley Leads an Uneven Emotional Story of Love and Loss on Prime Video

Love of Your Life follows a woman navigating grief and rediscovering herself after a devastating loss. Margaret Qualley anchors this emotional romantic drama, although uneven pacing and familiar storytelling prevent it from reaching its full potential.

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 8 Review: Peak Ragebait Series

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 8 continues the complicated relationship drama surrounding Ho and Mi-do, as unresolved feelings and strained relationships keep their romantic journey uncertain.

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 7 Review: When Love Becomes Too Painful to Hide

A Love Other Than Yours Episode 7 explores broken trust, complicated feelings and a painful love triangle as Ho and Mi-do struggle to repair their relationship while Tae-seung’s dark past adds new tension.

Carrie Series Ending Explained: Does Carrie Die? What Happens in the Shocking Finale?

Carrie ends with a devastating prom-night tragedy that changes the fate of Carrie, Margaret and Chamberlain. Here’s the ending explained, including the finale’s biggest twists and its surprising telekinetic reveal.
One Night in Idaho: The College Murders is a hard-hitting watch and will leave you heartbroken and confused.One Night in Idaho: The College Murders Review: A Confusing, Heinous Crime Told Well