The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3 has managed to do something rare in television today: ignite passionate debates that feel as heated as real-life rivalries. With Season 3 on the horizon, fans are once again divided between Team Conrad and Team Jeremiah, the two brothers who both hold a piece of Belly’s heart. While Jeremiah may bring fun, warmth, and safety, Conrad embodies the kind of love that’s deep, complex, and unforgettable. And if Season 3 follows the true spirit of the story, then Team Conrad should absolutely win the endgame.
The Roots of the Love Triangle
To understand why Conrad deserves to be Belly’s final choice, we have to look back at how this love triangle began. Belly has known both Fisher boys since childhood, but Conrad was always the one who seemed untouchable. His brooding presence, quiet protectiveness, and hidden vulnerability created an irresistible pull. Jeremiah, on the other hand, was the sunshine, always playful, always there to make her laugh.
The first two seasons showed the push-and-pull of these dynamics. Season 1 captured Belly’s long-standing crush on Conrad finally blossoming into something real. But his emotional distance and family struggles made him retreat, leaving her heartbroken. Season 2 shifted the spotlight to Jeremiah, whose reliability and openness seemed like a safe harbour during turbulent times. Still, viewers could feel that Belly’s bond with Conrad ran deeper than her light-hearted romance with Jeremiah.
Jeremiah vs Conrad: Two Different Kinds of Love
Fans often frame the debate as a battle between stability and passion. Jeremiah represents safety. He’s open with his feelings, quick to express affection, and provides Belly with the kind of love that doesn’t demand much risk. In contrast, Conrad represents intensity. His love is not as easily spoken but felt in gestures, moments of sacrifice, and the way he sees Belly beyond just the surface.
When Belly is with Jeremiah, it often feels sweet but fleeting, like a summer crush. With Conrad, it feels like destiny—messy, complicated, but enduring. Season 2’s finale highlighted this difference. Even as Belly leaned on Jeremiah, her eyes and her heart always drifted back to Conrad. The narrative itself seems to whisper that one love is transitional, while the other is transformative.
Conrad’s Growth and Redemption Arc
A common criticism of Conrad is that he can be moody, withdrawn, and even cold at times. But this criticism often overlooks what he has endured. Conrad carries the weight of his family’s grief, especially the loss of his mother, in ways Jeremiah never had to. His distance wasn’t about a lack of love for Belly but about his struggle to hold himself together while everything around him fell apart.
Season 3 offers the perfect opportunity for Conrad’s redemption arc. We’ve already seen glimpses of his growth—moments where he lets his guard down, where he protects Belly without expecting anything in return, where his love for her cuts through his silence. If Jeremiah’s strength is consistency, Conrad’s is evolution. He isn’t perfect, but he’s learning, and that journey makes his love story with Belly far more compelling.
Why Jeremiah Isn’t the Endgame
Jeremiah is lovable, no doubt. He’s easygoing, emotionally transparent, and makes Belly feel wanted. But sometimes what feels “easy” doesn’t last. His relationship with Belly in Season 2 felt like a reaction to Conrad’s retreat rather than a natural progression of its own. It’s telling that Belly herself admitted she wasn’t over Conrad even while being with Jeremiah.
Jeremiah may give Belly affection, but he doesn’t challenge her the way Conrad does. Their connection lacks the depth and intensity of the Conrad-Belly dynamic. Simply put, Jeremiah feels like the boy you date in your teens, while Conrad feels like the man you choose for life.
The Literary Canon Already Chose
Fans of the book trilogy already know how the story ends—Belly chooses Conrad. While TV adaptations sometimes deviate from their source material, the core essence of Han’s novels lies in this decision. The author crafted Conrad as Belly’s true love, the one she always came back to no matter how far she drifted. Changing that would not only alienate the loyal readers but also rob the series of its central emotional payoff.
Belly’s Emotional Journey
At the heart of the series is Belly’s growth from a girl swept up in her crushes to a young woman capable of making her own choices. Choosing Conrad doesn’t mean choosing the easier path—it means recognising that real love isn’t always straightforward. Her attraction to Jeremiah reflects her desire for comfort, but her connection with Conrad reflects her deeper maturity. By Season 3, Belly’s arc is about making peace with her feelings and understanding that the kind of love worth fighting for is often the one that scares you.
The Power of Enduring Love
Another reason Team Conrad deserves the endgame is the sheer longevity of his love for Belly. From the early days at Cousins Beach, Conrad noticed her transformation long before anyone else did. He may not have always expressed it, but his actions—his protectiveness, his subtle admiration, his sacrifices—speak louder than words.
In contrast, Jeremiah’s love bloomed later, almost as if prompted by Conrad’s withdrawal. This difference matters. Conrad’s love feels like a thread woven through the entire narrative, while Jeremiah’s feels like a chapter in the middle.
What Season 3 Needs to Deliver
For Season 3 to do justice to the story, it must show Conrad not just as the brooding love interest but as a man capable of growth, vulnerability, and honesty. It should highlight his willingness to fight for Belly rather than retreating into silence. Their relationship deserves moments of openness where Belly finally hears from Conrad’s own lips how much she means to him.
At the same time, the show must handle Jeremiah with care. He deserves closure, not vilification. His role in Belly’s life was meaningful, but Season 3 should make clear that his chapter has ended, and Conrad is the one who completes the book.
Final Thoughts: Why Conrad Must Be the Endgame
When all is said and done, The Summer I Turned Pretty is not just about teenage romance. It’s about growing up, learning to love deeply, and making choices that shape your future. Jeremiah offers comfort, but Conrad offers a love that transforms Belly into who she is meant to become.
Team Conrad deserves the endgame because his love is not only the truest but also the bravest. It is love that withstood grief, silence, and mistakes yet never wavered in its depth. Season 3 should give us the resolution that fans—and the story itself—have been waiting for: Belly choosing Conrad not just as her summer crush, but as her forever.
The Summer I Turned Pretty Season 3 is streaming on Prime Video.
Also read: 5 Best Moments from Aema That Had Everyone Talking